This Blog has now moved to idebate.org/worlddebating - all future posts will be made there!

16 May 2004

Singapore WUDC 2004 Summary

2004 Nanyang Technological University

Nanyang Technological University had defeated Malaysia and Croatia for the right to host. Before the competition, Singapore faced several difficulties. Their Chief Adjudicator, Amanda Kiemas, resigned to take up a new job offer. The replacement, Ravi Viswanathan, was a relative unknown and this caused some concern when he initially announced that he would speak in Stellenbosch and not adjudicate. This would have meant he had no adjudication experience at Worlds prior to being Chief Adjudicator. However he did adjudicate break rounds up to and including the semi-finals in Stellenbosch and their bid was ratified by the Council in Toronto.

After that, concerns were raised in 2003 by the SARS virus sweeping through Asia, but in reality it was not a serious threat to the championships. After all this, the championships themselves were a great success.

The Middle Temple team (Alexander Deane & Jeremy Brier) unanimously defeated Sydney (Alex Croft & Ani Satchithananda), Singapore Institute of Management (Rajesh Krishnan & Amit Bhatia) and Inner Temple (Richard Osbourne & Alexis Hearnden) in the final, held before a packed audience at the Victoria Concert Hall. Alex Croft was the best speaker.

Worlds Council, however, did not run so smoothly. The Council refused to ratify Zagreb as hosts for 2005. The bidding was reopened, and Malaysia's Multimedia University bid unopposed. After all that, University College Dublin won the right to host in 2006, again unopposed.

 
Winner:
Middle Temple (Alex Deane & Jeremy Brier)

Runners Up:
Sydney A (Alex Croft & Ani Satchithananda)
Singapore Institute of Management A (Rajesh Krishnan & Amit Bhatia)
Inner Temple (Richard Osborne & Alexis Hearnden)

Best Speaker
Alex Croft (Sydney A)

World Debating Masters Competition
Winner:
Australia (Tim Sonnreich & Amanda Wolthuizen)

Runners up:
England (Jack Anderson and Tom Hay)
Malaysia (Praba Ganesan and Suthen)
Canada (Ranjan and Rahool Agarwal)

English as a second Lanugage
Winner:
National University of Singapore B (Sarala Subramaniam & Wong Chen Seong)

Runners up:
National University of Malaysia A (UKM A) (Pravin Peraba and Khor Swee Kheng)
Ateneo De Manila E (John Fajardo and Bianca Rodriguez)
International Islamic University of Malaysia D (Raihan Ismail and Irma Nur Zaharah)

World Public Speaking Championships
Winner:
Irma Nurzahran Bt. Junian (International Islamic University

Runners up:
Greg Allen (University of British Columbia)
Sharon Ohayon (University of Alberta)

Comedy
Winner:
Mathew Kenneally (ANU)

Runners up:
Kevin Moar
Logan Balavijendran

Singapore WUDC 2004 Motions

Day 1:

1. TTHW try Saddam Hussein before an international tribunal
2. TTH supports all forms of child labour
3. TTHB eviormentalists should use terrorism in support of their goals

Day 2:
4. TTHB students all round the world should be taught in English
5. TTHW tie world bank aid to womens' rights
6. TTHW make the release of child sexual abusers conditional on chemical castration

Day 3:
7. TTH believes only African countries should be peacekeepers in African conflicts
8. TTH would use international sporting events for political change
9. TTH would ban religious symbols in state schools

Octo-finals:
TTH would support regime change in Iran

Quarters:
TTH believes parents should cast proxy votes for their children

Semis:
TTH believes war journalists should be forced to reveal their sources in international criminal tribunals

Final:
TTH would ban the abortion of fetuses on the grounds of their permanent disability

ESL Semi
TTH prefers regional trade agreements to the WTO

ESL Final
TTH believes that Japanese armed forces should fight in foreign lands.

Singapore WUDC 2004 Knockout results

Winners

Middle Temple A (Alex Deane & Jeremy Brier)

Finalists:
University of Sydney Union A (Alex Croft & Ani Satchithananda)
Inner Temple A (Richard Osborne & Alexis Hearnden)
Singapore Institute of Management A (Rajesh Krishnan & Amit Bhatia)

Semi-finalists
Cambridge University C (Beth O Connor & David Peters)
University of Auckland A (Jesse Wilson & Jonathan Orpin)
University of Bristol A (Can Okar & Nye Brewer)
Queens University B (Kevin Massie & Michael Saposnick)

Qtr-finalists
Ateneo de Manila University C (Leloy Claudio & Jess Lopez)
Lincolns Inn A (Sebastian Isaac & Nicholas Pacheco)
Mcgill B (Gaurav Toshniwal & Theo McLauchlin)
Monash University B (Andrew Fitch & Kylie Lane)
Oxford Union B (David Penny & Rachel Carrell)
Oxford Union C (Peggy Pao & Bob Cuffe)
Oxford Union E (Wang Yining & Gavin Illsley)
Trinity College Dublin B (Manus De Barra & Alison McIntyre)

Octo-Finalists
ANU C (Patrick Delaney & Matthew Kenneally)
Cambridge A (Jolene Tan & Patrick Emerson)
McGill A (Konrad Koncewicz, Ren)
Ottawa Law (Jamie Furniss & Erik Eastaugh)
NYU A (Neil Vakharia & Amanda Entin)
Oxford D (Molyneux & Jonathan Bailey)
UCD Law A (Michael Clarke & Eoghan Casey)
ANU A (Paul Barnsley & Emily Byrne)
Macquarie B
Oxford A (Tara Mounce & Nick Sloboda)
UCD L & H B (Noel Mcgrath & Ciaron Lawler)
UWA A
Cape Town A (Rob Garlick & Kate Orkin)
Yale A (Joe Ross & Rory Gillis)
UNSW A (Richard Howard & Peter Van Onselen)
Grays Inn (Louis Mooney & Emmet Coldrick)